Review: Monster The Lizzie Borden Story Fails To Deliver

Ryan Murphy is back with a brand new chapter in his true crime anthology. This time, the focus shifts to the infamous Lizzie Borden case. Fans of the franchise might find themselves let down by how the show handles the historical facts. Instead of sticking to the real history, the series chooses to lean heavily into a romantic filter and fictional plot points.

The show stars Ella Beatty as Lizzie, alongside Rebecca Hall and Charlie Hunnam. Rather than exploring the true complexity of the family dynamic, the script alters key relationships to make the main character more sympathetic. Real history points to an abusive father, but the drama swaps this for a wicked stepmother. Important figures like Lizzie's sister are practically pushed aside, which takes away from the depth of the original events.

Another major issue for viewers is the show's reluctance to let its female subjects simply be bad. By framing the notorious murders through a lens of romance and past trauma, the series turns brutal killers into misunderstood anti heroes. Even other historical figures like Elizabeth Bathory get the same treatment, turning complex real life events into simple tales of a society wronged.

If you enjoy high drama with stylish visuals, you might still find some entertainment here. However, anyone hoping for a faithful retelling of the famous trial will likely walk away frustrated. The series is currently available to watch for fans curious to see this new take on the classic crime.