Review: Below (2026) Struggles With Its Own Waters

Below is the latest horror thriller to hit Netflix, and it brings a unique, grounded setting to the screen. Set in a small Newfoundland town grappling with the aftermath of historic fishery collapses, the show introduces us to Calvin Penney. Played by Josh Hartnett, Calvin is a grieving widower trying to provide for his family while a mysterious and deadly sea creature begins terrorizing his community during a massive reunion event.

Creator Jesse McKeown does a great job of building a town that feels lived in and weary. The focus on regional details and the lasting trauma of government led resettlement programs adds a lot of heart to the narrative. You can really feel the tension between the younger generation trying to leave for a better life and the older residents who feel anchored to their home, despite the growing dangers emerging from the ocean.

However, the show hits a rough patch in its second half. While the first three episodes are tense and focused, the story begins to wander as characters split up. Some of the side plots feel forced, and characters like the marine researcher Fonda Howander, played by Mackenzie Davis, often feel like they exist only to explain the plot rather than grow as people. It is a shame, as the monster mystery itself is quite compelling.

Despite these pacing issues, Below succeeds as a moody, atmospheric watch. It uses its creature feature premise to touch on real environmental concerns, even if the execution sometimes feels a bit messy. If you enjoy character driven horror with a touch of social commentary, it is worth a look, though it might not land perfectly for everyone.